Skip to content
Savour
Seasonal and holidays

Vegetarian Thanksgiving Menu (US, 2026): 3 Mains and the Sides That Fit

A vegetarian Thanksgiving menu for US Thanksgiving on November 26, 2026: 3 mains in place of turkey, 19 starters, sides and desserts, and labels to check.

By

Published · 9 min read

Jump to the recipes
A small lasagna baked in a white rectangular dish on a plate, its golden, bubbling top of melted cheese and creamy orange sauce sprinkled with chopped parsley
Pictured: Butternut Squash Lasagna

For US Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, 2026, this vegetarian Thanksgiving menu has three Savour mains to put where the turkey would go: butternut squash lasagna (serves 10, about 19 g protein per serving, estimate), pumpkin mac and cheese (serves 6, about 21 g) and wild rice stuffed acorn squash (serves 4, about 10 g, listed vegan).

The rest of the dinner is already covered. The menu adds 19 dishes from the Thanksgiving recipes collection, each listed as vegetarian as written: 3 starters, 8 sides, 7 desserts and a hot drink. Five of the 22 are listed vegan. Strict vegetarians have four labels to read, all flagged by the recipes themselves: Parmesan, cheddar, broth and store-bought pie crust.

Vegetarian Thanksgiving menu: courses, total times, servings and diets

Total times and servings are as stored on each recipe. Every dish is listed vegetarian; "Also listed" adds the vegan and gluten-free listings, and the last column is the part the recipe's notes say can be made ahead, with the longest time they allow.

CourseRecipeTotal timeServesAlso listedMake ahead
MainButternut Squash Lasagna2 h 5 min10n/aYes: assembled, 24 hours
MainPumpkin Mac and Cheese30 min6n/aPart: baked version, 1 day
MainWild Rice Stuffed Acorn Squash1 h 20 min4Vegan, gluten-freePart: filling, 2 days
StarterSlow Cooker Butternut Squash Soup6 h 20 min6Vegan, gluten-freeYes: keeps 5 days
StarterAutumn Apple Walnut Salad20 min6Gluten-freePart: dressing and walnuts, 1 week
StarterAir Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms35 min8n/aPart: stuffed caps, 1 day
SideSlow Cooker Stuffing with Cranberries4 h12n/aPart: bread 3 days, vegetables 1 day
SideSlow Cooker Mashed Potatoes4 h 5 min12Gluten-freeYes: 2 days
SideSlow Cooker Mac and Cheese2 h 25 min10n/aNo: holds on WARM up to 1 hour
SideGreen Beans Almondine22 min6Gluten-freePart: blanched beans, 1 day
SideAir Fryer Brussels Sprouts22 min4Gluten-freeNo: serve straight away
SideAir Fryer Honey Glazed Carrots26 min4Gluten-freePart: carrots 2 days, glaze on the day
SideAir Fryer Butternut Squash35 min4Vegan, gluten-freeNo note: cooked cubes keep 4 days
SideEasy Orange Cranberry Sauce2 h 17 min8Vegan, gluten-freeYes: 10 days
DessertClassic Pumpkin Pie3 h 35 min8n/aYes: 1 to 2 days
DessertSweet Potato Pie3 h 50 min8n/aYes: 1 to 2 days
DessertClassic Pecan Pie4 h 20 min10n/aYes: keeps 4 days in the fridge
DessertDutch Apple Pie4 h 30 min8n/aYes: 1 day
DessertEasy Apple Crisp1 h 20 min8n/aYes: 1 day; topping 3 days
DessertPumpkin Roll3 h 45 min10n/aYes: 2 days
DessertPumpkin Cheesecake8 h 50 min12n/aYes: 3 days
DrinkSlow Cooker Mulled Apple Cider2 h 35 min8Vegan, gluten-freeYes: 5 days

Five are slow cooker recipes and four are air fryer recipes, so the oven is needed only for the lasagna, the stuffed squash, the baked mac and cheese and the desserts.

What is a good vegetarian main dish for Thanksgiving?

Pick by headcount: the three mains serve 10, 6 and 4.

  • Butternut squash lasagna, for a full table. Squash roasted at 220°C (425°F), a sage and garlic béchamel, mozzarella and Parmesan are layered between 12 noodles, then baked at 190°C (375°F) for 25 minutes covered and 20 to 25 minutes uncovered, until the centre reaches 74°C (165°F). Total 2 h 5 min (30 prep + 80 cook + 15 rest). It cuts into 10 pieces, at about 460 calories and 19 g protein per serving (estimate), and it is one of Savour's lasagna recipes.
  • Pumpkin mac and cheese, the quickest. Total 30 min (10 prep + 20 cook) on the stovetop, serves 6, at about 520 calories and 21 g protein per serving (estimate), the most protein of the three. A variation bakes it under a panko crumb at 190°C (375°F) for 20 to 25 minutes. The other versions are in mac and cheese recipes.
  • Wild rice stuffed acorn squash, the vegan main. Two squash, halved, give 4 servings of half a squash each, filled with wild rice, mushrooms, cranberries and pecans. Total 1 h 20 min (20 prep + 60 cook), at about 470 calories and 10 g protein per serving (estimate). It is also listed gluten-free; its tip says to check the label of a wild rice blend.

Which Thanksgiving starters and sides are already vegetarian?

All 3 starters and 8 sides in the table are listed vegetarian as written.

Starters and a drink. The slow cooker butternut squash soup serves 6, is listed vegan and cooks on LOW for 6 to 8 hours or on HIGH for 3 to 4 (how the two settings compare across recipes is in slow cooker low vs high). The autumn apple walnut salad takes 20 minutes and serves 6. The air fryer stuffed mushrooms recipe makes 24, enough for 8, air fried at 180°C (350°F) for 8 to 10 minutes. The slow cooker mulled apple cider fills 8 mugs and holds on WARM for up to 4 hours.

Sides. Three come from the slow cooker and feed a crowd: slow cooker stuffing with cranberries (serves 12), slow cooker mashed potatoes (serves 12) and slow cooker mac and cheese (serves 10). Three come from the air fryer, each serving 4 in 22 to 35 minutes: air fryer Brussels sprouts, air fryer honey glazed carrots and air fryer butternut squash. Green beans almondine (22 minutes, serves 6) and the easy orange cranberry sauce (12 minutes of cooking, serves 8) are made on the stovetop.

Which Thanksgiving desserts are vegetarian?

All seven desserts in the table are listed vegetarian: four pies (classic pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie, classic pecan pie and Dutch apple pie), the easy apple crisp, the pumpkin roll and the pumpkin cheesecake. None is listed vegan: each uses butter, eggs or both.

The cheesecake serves 12, the pecan pie and the pumpkin roll 10, and the other four 8. The apple crisp is the shortest at 1 h 20 min in total; the cheesecake's 8 h 50 min includes 420 minutes of cooling and chilling. All seven are in dessert recipes.

What should strict vegetarians check: cheese, broth and marshmallows?

The diet lists describe each recipe as written. These label checks come from the recipes' own tips and ingredient lines:

  • Parmesan. The lasagna and stuffed mushroom tips say Parmesan is traditionally made with animal rennet, and the protected-origin rules for Parmigiano Reggiano allow only calf rennet. Both tips suggest a vegetarian hard cheese; the lasagna tip adds a mozzarella made with microbial or vegetable rennet. Parmesan is also optional on the Brussels sprouts and part of the crumb topping on the baked pumpkin mac and cheese.
  • Cheddar. The pumpkin mac and cheese tip says many cheddars are made with microbial rennet, but not all. The slow cooker mac and cheese uses 340 g sharp cheddar, so read that label too.
  • Broth. The stuffing (600 ml), the mashed potatoes (240 ml) and the squash filling (600 ml) use vegetable broth, and the soup uses vegetable stock. The stuffing tip says to use vegetable broth to keep it vegetarian.
  • Pie crust. The sweet potato pie's ingredient line warns that some store-bought crusts contain lard. The pumpkin, pecan and Dutch apple pies allow a store-bought crust too.
  • Marshmallows. The slow cooker sweet potato casserole is not listed as vegetarian, so it is not on this menu: its tip says most marshmallows contain gelatin and suggests gelatin-free ones, or none and double the pecans.

Which Thanksgiving dishes are vegan?

Five are listed vegan as written: the stuffed acorn squash, the butternut squash soup, the air fryer butternut squash, the cranberry sauce and the mulled cider. That gives a vegan guest a main, a starter, two sides and a drink with no changes.

Four more have a vegan swap in their own variations or FAQs:

  • Green beans almondine: 2 tbsp olive oil instead of the butter.
  • Honey glazed carrots: maple syrup for the honey and olive oil for the butter.
  • Brussels sprouts: skip the Parmesan and finish with lemon and a pinch of chili flakes; the glaze line already offers maple syrup or honey.
  • Apple walnut salad: leave out the goat cheese or use a dairy-free cheese.

Ten of the 22 are also listed gluten-free, as the table shows. The mashed potato tip says to check that the broth is labelled gluten-free.

What can you make ahead for a vegetarian Thanksgiving?

Most of it: 19 of the 22 recipes have a make-ahead tag or note. Counting back from US Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, 2026, this is the earliest day for each, within the limit its recipe gives. Any later day works too.

Earliest dayDays beforeWhat can be made
Monday, November 1610Cranberry sauce
Thursday, November 197Salad dressing and toasted walnuts
Saturday, November 215Soup; mulled cider, strained
Sunday, November 224Pecan pie (its fridge time)
Monday, November 233Pumpkin cheesecake; stuffing bread, dried; apple crisp topping
Tuesday, November 242Pumpkin roll; pumpkin and sweet potato pies; mashed potatoes; squash filling; carrots, unglazed
Wednesday, November 251Lasagna, assembled; baked mac and cheese, assembled without its topping; stuffed mushrooms; blanched green beans; stuffing vegetables; salad greens, washed; Dutch apple pie and apple crisp, baked

To start earlier, the lasagna freezes baked or unbaked for up to 3 months and thaws overnight in the fridge; can you freeze lasagna compares the freezer notes and reheating times.

On Thursday, bake the lasagna straight from the fridge at 190°C (375°F), adding 10 to 15 minutes to the covered time, until the centre reaches 74°C (165°F). The baked mac and cheese goes in covered at 180°C (350°F) for 20 minutes, then gets its topping and 20 to 25 minutes more, uncovered. Roast the acorn squash, fill it with the cold filling and bake it for 15 to 20 minutes. The mashed potatoes reheat in the microwave with a splash of milk until steaming hot throughout, 74°C (165°F). The soup and the cider reheat on the stove, which leaves the slow cooker free for the stuffing: it is mixed with its eggs and broth just before it cooks on LOW for 3 to 4 hours.

Three dishes have no make-ahead note and are cooked on the day: the slow cooker mac and cheese, the Brussels sprouts and the air fryer butternut squash. The mac and cheese cooks on LOW for 2 to 2 1/2 hours and the stuffing for 3 to 4, so serving both at once takes two slow cookers. The salad is tossed just before serving. More dishes with a make-ahead note are on the make-ahead recipes page.

How many people does each vegetarian main serve?

The lasagna serves 10, the pumpkin mac and cheese 6 and the stuffed squash 4. When a turkey is on the table as well, the squash or the mac and cheese covers a few vegetarian guests, and every other dish in the table already fits. The lasagna suits a dinner where everyone shares the main.

Fourteen of the 22 recipes serve 8 or more as written: the lasagna, stuffed mushrooms, stuffing, mashed potatoes, slow cooker mac and cheese, cranberry sauce, cider and all seven desserts. The soup, salad, green beans and pumpkin mac and cheese serve 6. The three air fryer sides and the squash serve 4; their steps say to work in batches when the basket is crowded. The servings control on each recipe page scales the ingredients, not the times. For other headcounts, how many potatoes per person works from the mashed potatoes' 2.3 kg for 12 servings.

More vegetarian Thanksgiving recipes

See every Thanksgiving recipe

Recipes in this post (22)